A Deep Dive Into Workers’ Comp Stats

by Frank Huang | March 3, 2020

Originally published in PEO Insider (March 2020)
Reproduced with permission of the National Association of Professional Employer Organizations

Over the past decade, the workers’ compensation (WC) industry experienced the quintessential highs and lows of a market cycle. The goal of this article is to share and discuss recent trends in both the WC and PEO WC space sand provide thoughts on the direction of the market over the next year. We will wrap up the article by sharing some ideas that PEO leadership and risk management professionals can consider to prepare themselves for the more challenging times that will inevitably come.

TRENDS TO DATE: ENTIRE WC INDUSTRY

The broader WC industry has experienced some of its highest levels of profitability in recent history, especially compared to how the decade began. Calendar year (CY) 2010 saw the lowest net written premium (NWP) and highest combined ratio (CR) in the last nine years. Both metrics have steadily improved in the years that followed, leading to a projected CY 2018 NWP that increased almost 40 percent and a projected CY 2018 CR that is more than 30 points lower than 2010. NWP includes both National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) states and state insurance funds such as California and Texas. Combined ratios are only for private carriers. This data is from NCCI’s 2019 State of the Line Presentation. See Figure 1.


Underlying frequency and severity trends for indemnity claims also continue the same trajectory since 2010, with severity increasing an average of 2 percent annually through 2018, but frequency driving the overall high-level favorable trends with an average annual decrease of almost 4 percent. See Figure 2.


All of this has led to numerous rate decreases since 2010, with 2018 rates projected to be 22 percent less than they were in 2010, as shown in Figure 3.

TRENDS TO DATE: PEO WC INDUSTRY

Just as the broader industry is growing in scale and profit, similar favorable trends can be seen in the PEO WC space, according to NAPEO’s 2019 Financial Ratio & Operating Statistics (FROS) survey. The average experience mod, average change in premium rate, and average change in required collateral all decreased over the past seven years. More specifically the FROS survey showed, from 2012 to 2018:

  • The average experience mod decreased from 0.95 (2012) to 0.90 (2018), as shown in Figure 4;
  • The average change in premium rate decreased from 7.1 to 3.0 percent, as shown in Figure 5; and
  • The average change in collateral decreased from 7.3 to 5.7 percent, as shown in Figure 6.

Despite the attractiveness of strong recent profitability, the percentage of PEOs on guaranteed cost plans has remained relatively flat across all members that participated in the FROS survey, as shown in Figure 7.


It is worth noting that the FROS survey reflects mostly PEOs with fewer than 5,000 worksite employees (WSEs). For PEOs with more than 5,000 WSEs, the percentage of PEOs using guaranteed cost plans has actually decreased by more than 10 percent. 

FIGURE 8. PERCENTAGE OF LARGE PEOS ON GUARANTEED COST PLANS.

PREPARING FOR ROUGH WATERS

While no one can predict how the macroeconomic winds will blow in 2020, conventional wisdom is that there isn’t an overwhelming number of indications pointing to a hardening market in the next 12 months. The main reason behind this expectation is that improvements in and greater adoption of technology have helped to lower indemnity claims frequency. As investment in technology is expected to continue in both the broader WC and PEO WC spaces, downward frequency trends are expected to continue, likely making for a favorable 2020 WC climate.

However, PEOs would be wise to prepare for future inclement weather. As a rising tide lifts all boats, when the tide recedes, it may reveal risk management shortcomings without adequate time to make necessary improvements.

What can PEOs do now to improve their WC programs? Examine the entire WC life cycle of prospects turned clients, and make sure there are no weak spots. More specifically, PEOs can:

  • Make sure evaluation and pricing are sound, considering both actual and expected experience;
  • Ensure renewal pricing meets the firm’s long-term business goals;
  • Handle claims appropriately by complexity, with greater potential for savings in the most complex claims;
  • Use safety consultants to drive savings and not just maintain stability; and
  • Approach policy renewals and collateral negotiations with a clear understanding of the book’s risk characteristics and experience.

All of these things can be accomplished with improved practices within the organization, and also by using talent and technology from outside your organization. In fact, the PEO industry could take a page from the insurance industry’s book and learn from its use of analytics to drive favorable trends.

While the above suggestions may seem like a big ask, especially for smaller PEOs, implementing even relatively simple risk management practices might benefit your firm greatly and potentially accelerate your firm’s progress towards the future.

TAKE-AWAYS

The PEO WC space has mirrored the broader WC industry over the last decade, with a favorable environment expected to continue into 2020 for both. However, the PEO industry may want to proactively consider making improvements in their businesses before these trends begin to shift. PEOs that are prepared for the future will get there in far better condition than those that aren’t.

Frank Huang has more than 15 years of actuarial consulting experience serving a wide range of clients, including serving as ADP’s Chief Actuary.  Learn more about our PEO consulting practice here.